Access is not Consent: Lessons from DPLAN v. Truecaller

Introduction

The case of Incorporated Trustees of the Data Privacy Lawyers Association (DPLAN) v. Truecaller International LLP (“DPLAN v. Truecaller”) raises important questions about consent and accountability in data protection. The applicants challenged Truecaller’s collection, processing and display of telephone numbers and associated identities belonging to non-users who had not consented to such processing. In considering the dispute under Section 37 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (the “CFRN”) and the Nigeria Data Protection Act 2023 (the “NDPA”), the Court rejected the proposition that one user’s consent extends automatically to others whose data appears in their contact list. However, it dismissed the application for failure to establish a breach of fundamental rights through cogent and credible evidence. This article examines the Court’s reasoning on consent, data controller accountability, the burden of proof and Truecaller’s public safety justification, alongside the implications for organisations processing third-party personal data.

You may read the entire document here